Puzzle Pack #2 Puzzle 33 Answer

Zoe’s clue says that Logan is one of the exactly 2 innocents above Xavi. That directly identifies Logan as innocent. So Logan must be innocent.

Logan’s clue says row 5 is the only row with exactly one innocent. Row 5 already has one known innocent, Zoe. That means the other three people in row 5 cannot be innocent, because that would give row 5 more than one innocent instead of exactly one. So Tina, Uma, and Xavi must be criminals.

Xavi’s clue says exactly 2 innocents above Xavi are neighboring Oscar. In the shared group identified for this step, there is currently 1 known innocent, Logan, and no unknown people left in that shared group. Since the clue requires 2 innocents there, the remaining target from Oscar’s neighbors for this step, Phil, has to supply the second innocent. So Phil must be innocent.

Zoe’s clue says Logan is one of exactly 2 innocents above Xavi. The people above Xavi are Celia, Gus, Logan, and Phil, and Logan and Phil are already the 2 known innocents there. If Celia and Gus were innocent as well, that same group above Xavi would have more than 2 innocents, which clashes with the clue. So Celia and Gus must be criminal.